Between a storm door vs screen door, which one would better suit your entryway? If you’re still on the fence, don’t worry! Both have their unique perks and with so many options out there, it’s time to take a closer look.
In this guide, let’s debate storm door vs screen door, weigh the pros and cons, and figure out which one is made for you.
Contents
What is a Screen Door?
A screen door is a lightweight door made of wood or metal frame fitted with a fine mesh screen. They’re installed outside exterior doors like the kitchen, laundry, front door, etc. The whole idea behind screen doors is to keep the solid door open and the screen door locked, letting in the air without worrying about swarms of bugs and security.
Pros of a Screen Door
- Good airflow: The breeze inside will keep the indoors cool, especially in rooms such as the kitchen, where good ventilation is fundamental.
- No bugs: The mesh screen blocks out annoying critters like flies and mosquitoes, which can save you from a possible germ or disease.
- Cost-effective: Because of simple components, most screen doors are very affordable.
- Easy installation: They’re lightweight and thus easy to install in multiple configurations like sliding screen doors.
- Multiple applications: You can put a screen door on any exterior door, like laundries, kitchens, patios, etc.
Cons of a Screen Door
- Only suitable for temperate climates.
- No energy-saving benefits since they don’t add a thermal barrier.
- Need more maintenance, mesh can get ripped or torn, especially if you have pets or young kids.
- Don’t provide much in terms of security.
What is a Storm Door?
A storm door is a secondary door that goes outside an entry door to shield it from the elements like rain, snow, and wind. They’re usually applied outside the main entry doors only.
Storm doors are typically more solid, made from durable materials like tempered glass or polycarbonate with aluminum or steel frames. Many come with weatherstripping for added insulation.
Hybrid Storm Doors with Retractable Screens
Modern hybrid storm doors also come with retractable or interchangeable panels. So you can simply retract the solid panels, like glass, and pull down a pre-installed mesh screen instead to let in fresh air. The screen then seamlessly rolls back up into the frame when you’re ready to close.
These multifunction storm doors are perfect for areas with changing weather—you get the strength to brace rough weather and the enjoyment of summer breeze in one package.
Benefits of a Storm Door
- Extend the Door’s Life: Storm doors take the brunt of the elements, which means the expensive door inside stays in shape for longer.
- Lower Energy Bills: The double-double barrier of the storm door and entry door, improves insulation, lowering the load on heating and cooling and ultimately saving on bills.
- Add Security: Storm doors come with strong frames and lockable options, an extra layer of security, making it harder for potential intruders to access your home.
- Seasonal Versatility: With the retractable panels, storm doors can fulfill all the benefits of the screen door. You can easily swap the glass for mesh in spring/summer and put it back in autumn to prepare for insulating needs in winter.
Cons of a Storm Door
- Can be bulky and heavy, which may make them harder to open, especially for young kids or the elderly.
- In hot weather, the glass panels can trap heat between the storm door and the main door, potentially damaging paint or warping wood.
- Mostly only applied on the main front door.
- Tend to be pricier due to their added features.
Table with Key Comparison of Storm Door vs Screen Door
| Feature | Storm Door | Screen Door |
| Purpose | Weather protection, security | Ventilation, insect protection |
| Material | Heavy-duty glass, metal frame | Mesh screen, lightweight frame |
| Application | Main front door | Any exterior door (e.g kitchen, patio) |
| Weather Resistance | High | Minimal |
| Ventilation | Adjustable with screen inserts | Excellent, with a fixed screen |
| Insulation | Yes | None |
| Longevity | Long, up to 20+ years | Short, 2-5 years |
| Aesthetic | Available in various styles and finishes | Simple design, usually not a focal point |
| Installation | Require professional handling | Easy, suitable for DIY |
| Security | Lockable, more secure | Low security |
| Maintenance | Minor, cleaning mostly | Higher, easily damaged |
| Cost | Higher | More affordable |
| Suitability | Harsh weather or energy savings | Mild climates with a focus on ventilation |
Takeaway: What is the Right Choice for You?
Between a storm door vs screen door, a storm door is ideal if you live somewhere with colder winters or unpredictable weather. It’s also great if you’re looking for added security. On the flip side, if ventilation is your main focus and you don’t need weather coverage, a screen door is a better, cost-effective choice.
For more options and top-notch craftsmanship in entryway doors, reach out to Mannlee Door and Window Producers. Our experts can help you find the perfect door solution for your home.
FAQs
Should I get a storm door or a screen door?
If you need all-weather protection plus security, go for a storm door. If you just want ventilation without letting the bugs in, a screen door is your answer.
When should you not use a storm door?
A storm door may be unnecessary in warm climates and little exposure of elements to your entry door. Additionally, if your inner door is already well-insulated, installing a storm door may not justify the minimal extra benefits.
What are the disadvantages of screen doors?
Since screen doors are essentially mesh, they don’t offer any security, and keeping your main door open alongside to allow ventilation may not end up safe. Storm doors also lack weather resistance and require maintenance.
Why are screen doors called storm doors?
While the terms are sometimes confused, screen doors and storm doors are different and serve different purposes. Screen doors have mesh while storm doors are solid, often made of tempered glass or polycarbonate.
