Iron vs steel doors are one of the strongest doors available for your space. Both materials provide durability, security, and a number of customizing options. But which one is most suitable for your space? Which style of door will provide you the best value for your money, and which will disappoint you in the long run?
Iron and steel both have pros and cons. In this article, we’ll go over what sets apart each door type so you can make the best decision on which is the best door for you.
Contents
Iron Doors
Iron doors, also known as wrought iron doors, are created of wrought iron that has been coated in a protective material and is often provided with glass panes for visibility and decor. Iron doors aren’t usually cheap, but they are known for lasting multiple lifetimes with little maintenance, and their use goes back past the Victorian era.
Wrought iron doors are also easily manufactured and tend to be available in a variety of design patterns. In most ways, you’ll find that an iron door is probably the best type of door on the market.
Steel Doors
Steel doors are unmatched in terms of strength and safety. While these doors have been present for ages, it wasn’t recognized as a reliable door material in the residential sector until just a few decades ago, and it was not commonly used until recently. These doors, though not as solid and reliable as wrought iron and not as appealing as solid wood, offer a highly durable door option at a reasonable price.
This is mainly due to the increased production of steel in the modern world, compared to standard wrought iron. It’s become less expensive to make, easier to obtain, and more easily recognized as a valuable resource.
Factors to Consider Before Buying A Door: Iron Vs. Steel
On the surface, iron vs steel doors appear to be similar. Unless you do research, you probably won’t think there were any major differences to consider and would simply get the lowest choice that looked good. However, this is not the most effective way. Here’s how they compare to one other.
Price
When deciding between wrought iron and steel doors, price is also an essential factor. Steel doors, on average, are less expensive than wrought iron doors. Wrought iron doors are more expensive to make, which can be seen in their price.
This means that homeowners on a limited budget could consider installing a steel door. However, it is important to remember that the cost of a door is not the only thing when making a purchase. It is also important to look at the door’s durability, security, and customization options.
Longevity
When picking a door material, durability is an important factor to consider. In terms of durability, wrought iron doors will survive a lifetime with little maintenance. Instead of rusting and causing structural damage, a wrought iron door develops a patina, or a faint, rainbow-like film, that provides elegance to its appearance and prevents far more serious harm.
Steel doors, while also durable, require more maintenance and rust easily when exposed to water without a protective layer, forcing you to replace a steel door as soon as a year after purchase, however this is a rare occurrence.
Security
Iron and steel doors offer high levels of security, making them ideal for protecting homes and businesses. Iron doors, on the other hand, are often seen as the gold standard of security due to their huge weight and strength. Their heavy, durable design makes them highly immune to forced entry, providing superior protection.
Steel doors provide strong security, particularly when reinforced with advanced locking systems, but they are more vulnerable to dents and scratches. These surface imperfections may eventually compromise the door’s ability to withstand strong impacts or force, potentially weakening its overall security if not well-maintained or fixed.
Aesthetic
Aesthetics are a key factor when selecting a front door. Wrought iron doors have a more traditional and ornate style, whereas steel doors are more modern and sleek. Wrought iron doors can add elegance and character to your space, whereas steel doors can give it an updated look.
Metal doors are shaped, which is the simplest and quickest way to manufacture a metal door while keeping costs low without sacrificing quality. This means that the metal that is easiest to mold will have more options. In this case, it is iron. Steel is difficult to mold into a door. It lacks the moldability required to create fine details and detailed designs. As a result, you will have a limited selection of design elements.
Installation
Both iron and steel door installation can be done without a professional, but the weight of the doors and the size of the job can make it difficult.
Most of the steel doors are lighter and hollow, which makes them simple to install yourself. It should not be a big problem because it’s easier for a professional team to install the door correctly for the first time.
Pros and Cons of Steel Doors
Pros
- Steel doors are an excellent choice for entryways as they are strong and durable, which makes them difficult to force open. Steel doors with proper locks and frames are used in commercial and residential settings where security is most important.
- These doors are strong and can withstand elements like rain, snow, and wind. They are less likely to warp, rot, or crack than other types of doors which makes them an excellent choice in harsh climates.
- They are an excellent insulator which helps in keeping your home warm in the winter and cool in the summer. Steel Doors can also help lower energy bills and provide better insulation than other door materials.
- They can be put in a variety of ways to suit various decorative styles, or they can be made to look like wood. Steel doors are available in a variety of designs, appearances, and finishes, so you may find one that matches the look of your space.
Cons
- Steel doors are easily dented and scratched. If their protective layer is harmed, they may rust, particularly in moist or coastal areas. Repairing dented doors can be challenging. These dents can impact a property’s look and curb appeal, even while they tolerate typical wear and tear.
- They provide few options for complex and decorative designs.Steel doors can be styled to have a modern or sleek appearance, but they lack excellent workmanship and creativity that iron doors offer. This limits their appeal to homeowners who want detailed, decorative features.
- While steel doors are not as heavy as iron doors, they are still much heavier than wood or fiberglass doors. This makes the installation difficult and due to this reason additional labor and extra door frames may be required for a good completion which increases the overall cost and effort.
- Steel doors might not provide as much sound or thermal insulation as other materials, especially if they are poorly insulated. Steel can conduct heat or cold more readily than other materials, which can affect indoor temperature and result in higher energy costs.
Pros and Cons of Iron Doors
Pros
- The aesthetic value of iron doors is difficult to match. These doors stand out due to their complex designs and pattern which make them a statement piece as they can improve the overall curb appeal of your space.
- Iron doors offer long-term benefits and they are highly resistant to extreme weather conditions. They offer high-level protection against break-ins and intruders that bring peace of mind.
- Little maintenance is required for these doors and they last much longer. They do not warp or rot, and their finish stays fresh for years which makes them an appealing long-term investment. To clean an iron door you need to use a simple soap and water solution.
- The striking look of iron doors increases its curb appeal which improves the overall appearance of a home or business. The combination of beauty and functionality not only improves its exterior but can also increase the property’s market value which makes them a unique feature in real estate.
Cons
- While iron doors have many advantages, one of the main disadvantages is their higher initial cost as compared to other door materials. However, they are a wise investment that will save you money due to their durability and lifespan.
- Although wrought iron is extremely durable, these doors are prone to rusting and as a result need regular maintenance to prevent corrosion. This maintenance consists of cleaning the doors and using anti-rust coatings.
- Iron doors may lack insulation which reduces the energy efficiency of your space. These doors may not provide the same level of energy savings as other materials due to the lack of insulation which result in higher utility bills.
- These doors are heavy which can make installation more difficult and expensive. The weight of these doors often requires reinforced door frames, specialized doors for a proper installation which raises the overall cost and time needed to install the door.
How Are Both Materials Similar?
Steel and iron doors have a number of important things in common that make them both great options for strong, safe entrances. These materials are among the most durable because of their strength and resistance to normal wear and tear. Both doors offer protection against illegal entry because of their strong security features.
Furthermore, both materials are fireproof, which adds an extra layer of safety. These doors help regulate indoor temperatures that result in energy savings. Although Iron offers greater customization than steel, both materials offer flexible design options that can blend in with a range of architectural styles. Overall, both iron and steel doors are strong, long-lasting, and secure, with each having its own unique advantages.
Iron VS Steel Doors: Which One Is Best
Steel and wrought iron both have advantages and disadvantages and the one you are going to choose depends on your specific demands and specifications. Iron doors are known for their durability, security, and traditional aesthetics, whereas steel doors are known for their sleek, modern appearance and cost-effectiveness. After taking into account every aspect, you should decide which solution best suits your requirements and preferences.
FAQ’S
What are the disadvantages of iron doors?
Because iron doors are heavy, installation is more complicated and expensive. They are also rust-prone, particularly in humid environments, and require regular maintenance. They may also cost more than other materials.
What are the disadvantages of a steel door?
If not properly maintained, steel doors are vulnerable to dents, scratches, and rust over time. They can cost more than wood doors and might not offer as much insulation as fiberglass doors.
Which is better, wrought iron or steel?
For aesthetics wrought iron works well because it is more durable and offers more decorative design options. Steel is usually a more practical choice because it is less expensive, easier to maintain, and offers superior insulation.
Is iron better than steel in any way?
Iron is the best material for durability because it is more robust and resistant to physical force. Although steel is usually less expensive and easier to maintain, it also allows for intricate designs.
Conclusion
Finally, the choice between iron vs steel doors is decided by your personal preferences, budget, and the architectural style of your space. Whether you want a stunning iron door with detailed work or a simple steel door for your space, we can help. Our team of specialists has the knowledge and experience to provide you with the best doors that complement your surroundings.
